At a glance
Al-Azhar University researchers tested green lacewing larvae on second-instar, third-instar and mixed citrus leafminer prey. Third instars cut development to 13 days and lifted survival to 80%, with implications for mass rearing and orchard releases.
A green lacewing larva fed nothing but third-stage citrus leafminer caterpillars finished its larval growth in 13 days. Given a mixture of every leafminer stage, the same species needed 19.9. That near seven-day gap is the core result of a laboratory study run at Al-Azhar University in Cairo and published in the Egyptian Academic Journal of Biological Sciences by Ahmed M. Gharib, Mohammad M. M. Megahed, Wael M. Sameer and Fouad A. F. Ali.
Both insects are common in citrus country, and they meet under conditions that matter to whoever owns the trees. The citrus leafminer, Phyllocnistis citrella, is a moth from South-East Asia that has become a pest of citrus in many parts of the world. Its larvae mine just beneath the leaf cuticle, leaving serpentine tunnels that drag down photosynthesis and leave young leaves curled. The green lacewing, Chrysoperla carnea, is a predator that growers and greenhouse managers already buy by the thousand.
The Cairo team found that the predator's own performance depends heavily on which stage of the pest it eats. Third-instar leafminer larvae, the largest of the feeding stages, produced the fastest development and the highest survival. Second instars were middling. The mixed diet was worst. That is a detail with practical weight, because a biological control programme lives or dies on how many healthy predators it can put into a field, and how quickly they get there.
What the Cairo team put in the dishes
The experiments ran in the Plant Protection laboratories at the Faculty of Agriculture in Nasr City, under conditions chosen to hold everything steady: 26±2°C, 65±5% relative humidity and 16 hours of light against 8 of dark.
Leafminer larvae came from the faculty's own citrus orchard. Infested leaves were collected daily, cleaned of other insects and sorted into three groups: leaves carrying only second instars, leaves carrying only third instars, and leaves carrying a mixture of the first, second, third and fourth instars. Lacewing eggs were bought from the biological control laboratory at Cairo University's Faculty of Agriculture and reared through to hatching.
Each newly hatched lacewing larva went into its own 9-by-2-centimetre Petri dish, with 30 dishes behind every diet. Once the predators pupated and emerged, adults were paired in 12-by-28-centimetre glass jars fitted with paper strips for egg-laying and fed an artificial diet of yeast, sugar and distilled water blended 4:7:10, following a standard recipe from 1976. Eggs were counted daily and moved to fresh dishes so the team could record how many hatched. The results went through one-way analysis of variance in Costat software, with significance set at 5%.
An instar, for readers who last met the word in a school textbook, is simply the stretch between two moults. A caterpillar outgrows its skin, splits it and starts a larger size class. The leafminer goes through four. The first three are sap-feeding grubs working inside the mine; the fourth stops feeding and spins the pupal chamber. The Cairo experiment therefore tested the predator against the two biggest feeding stages and against the full natural spread of prey, which is closer to what a lacewing meets on a badly infested leaf.
Think of it as a kitchen serving the same dish in three portion sizes while the diner's growth is charted. The surprise is that one single portion beat the mixed plate.
Faster development, more survivors
The effects landed on the larval stage and on survival. They did not touch the egg or pupal stages.
| Prey given to lacewing larvae | Larval period (days) | Larval survival | Pupal survival | Egg to adult (days) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Third-instar leafminer only | 13.00 ± 1.54 | 80% | 92% | 22.08 ± 2.02 |
| Second-instar leafminer only | 16.25 ± 1.54 | 66% | 62% | 25.58 ± 1.73 |
| Mixture of all instars | 19.91 ± 1.73 | 70% | 78% | 29.00 ± 2.45 |
Every difference in that table clears the study's own bar for statistical significance: the least significant difference at 5% came to 1.33 days for the larval period and 1.73 days for the egg-to-adult total. The gap between the third-instar diet and the mixed diet is more than four times the larval threshold.
The mixed treatment deserves a second look, because it contained third instars among all the others and still produced the slowest development of the three. Whatever the cause, the authors are direct about their conclusion: the third instar was the most preferred prey for C. carnea, and the life stage of the prey shapes the predator's population growth. The full paper is available from the journal's archive.
What the data show is that the life stage of the prey is not a neutral detail in a rearing programme, said Megahed, a researcher in the Plant Protection Department at Al-Azhar University. A colony built on third-instar leafminer reaches adulthood sooner and loses fewer individuals along the way, and that margin is what separates a supply line that can keep up with a grove from one that cannot.
The measurements that did not budge
Diet did not shift the incubation period, which ran from 3.00 days on third instars to 3.60 on second instars, a spread comfortably inside the 1.15-day least significant difference. The pupal period sat between 9.08 and 9.33 days across all three treatments. Adult longevity, and the pre-oviposition and post-oviposition periods, also came out statistically flat.
Two reproductive measures did move: the number of eggs a female laid and the proportion of those eggs that hatched. The paper reports both as significantly affected by diet without ranking the treatments on those traits in its abstract. The clearest practical advantages stay in development time and survival, which are the numbers a rearing facility plans around.
Why a citrus grower would care
Spraying is the standard answer to citrus leafminer, and in the paper's framing it is a poor one. The larvae sit inside the leaf, shielded from contact insecticides, so growers return to the orchard with the sprayer again and again. Biological control, the authors write, is generally regarded as the most economically sound and environmentally sustainable management practice for this pest.
The stakes go past cosmetic leaf damage. Leafminer tunnels open entry points for the citrus canker bacterium, Xanthomonas axonopodis pv. citri, and the paper cites a body of work on that association stretching back to the 1960s. Florida's citrus production guide is blunt about the consequence: tunnels infected by the canker pathogen produce many times the amount of inoculum than leaves without leafminer damage. The same guide notes the moth colonised some 860,000 acres within a year of its 1993 detection in the state, a history documented in USDA accounts of the eradication and biocontrol effort.
The green lacewing earns its place in that fight on several counts the paper lists. It occupies a wide geographical range and a broad set of habitats, searches well for prey, tolerates many of the insecticides growers apply, reproduces quickly, develops fast and is easy to rear in a laboratory. Its larvae do the killing. Adults feed only on nectar, pollen and honeydew, so a release has to be timed to the stage that eats.
Mass production is where the instar detail pays off. A colony moving from egg to adult in 22 days with 92% pupal survival yields more adults, more quickly, than one on a mixed diet at 29 days and 78%. The paper's own phrasing is that the results illustrate the potential importance of prey resources, meaning life stage, on C. carnea population growth. For a facility already juggling prey supply and climate cabinets, that is a scheduling decision, not a curiosity.
The limits of a growth chamber
Numbers from a climate-controlled room travel badly. The Cairo trial held temperature, humidity and day length constant, served prey on cut leaves in small dishes, and used one laboratory population of the predator. No field release was tested. Fecundity was recorded for females fed an artificial adult diet rather than the nectar and pollen they would find outdoors.
Other laboratories have landed on very different figures for the same pairing. A Spanish team working at 28°C reported that C. carnea could complete its cycle on third-instar leafminer but took 42 days, and that only one of 50 larvae reached adulthood, with mortality near 90% concentrated in the pupal stage, as described in their published field and laboratory assessment. Different colony, different temperature, different protocol. Neither result cancels the other. What they show together is that a laboratory benchmark tells you about a laboratory, and a grove has ants, hunting spiders, parasitoid wasps and August heat in it.
There is a statistical limit too. Analysis of variance compares average durations and survival rates. It does not build a life table, so the paper cannot report an intrinsic rate of increase for the predator on each diet, which is the demographic figure a rearing manager would want in order to know how fast a colony actually multiplies rather than how fast individuals grow.
Where the next experiment starts
The obvious follow-up is a field trial that staggers predator releases against the leafminer's own generations. The paper notes that leafminer populations peak in spring and summer, when citrus pushes new flush and temperatures climb, and third instars are plentiful on infested leaves by then. Timing releases to that window, rather than to a spray calendar, is the kind of change the Cairo data argue for.
A second question the 2014 work leaves open is whether the third-instar advantage carries into the next generation. The study found diet shifted both egg numbers and hatch rates but did not rank the diets on those traits. Pinning down which stage produces the most fertile daughters, rather than merely the most surviving ones, would sharpen the case for instar-specific rearing.
For a grower weighing a purchase order, the arithmetic is plain enough. A predator that reaches adulthood in 22 days rather than 29, with higher survival at both the larval and pupal stages, is one that can build numbers inside the flush period instead of after it has passed. As insecticide options narrow under resistance and regulation, a margin that size is what decides whether a biological programme earns its keep in an orchard.
- biological-control
- entomology
- integrated-pest-management
- citrus-leafminer
- chrysoperla-carnea

