Academic Jobs - Home of Higher Ed Logo

abolitionist movement: top 10 universities who lead the way

11 min read0 views

At a glance

Ten US universities that put money, admissions policy and degrees behind abolitionist work, plus the caveats their own announcements leave out.

a large building with a clock tower on top of it
Photo by Roxana Crusemire on Unsplash

Nobody keeps this ranking, which is the first honest thing to say

Ask which American universities lead on abolition and the honest answer starts with a confession: nobody measures it. There's no accrediting body for institutional repentance, no common unit in which a slavery report, a granite memorial and a prison degree can be compared. The rankings that do exist count endowment and citations. Neither has ever freed anyone.

So the list below is a judgment, and the criteria are on the table. Three things earn a place: a documented commitment that predates the current fashion; money or admissions policy attached to it rather than adjectives; and a record an outsider can check. Where an institution's own account and an independent one diverge, both are given. Where a number is an estimate, it says so.

Two movements, one word, no shared scoreboard

"Abolitionist" now covers two bodies of work that share a vocabulary and almost nothing else. One is historical: universities examining how they were built on enslaved labour and what they owe the descendants. The other is present-tense: prison abolition, the argument that carceral punishment should be reduced toward nothing, taught at Berkeley as a course on "abolition geographies" and at Vassar as a study of how slavery's abolition and prison abolition are connected "not just analogically but through a material account of their ideological and historical formation."

The two are easy to conflate in a press release and hard to conflate in a budget. A comparison is instructive.

Legacy of slavery workPrison abolition work
What it targetsThe institution's own history, endowment and admissionsThe carceral system the institution lives alongside
Typical unit of workCommission, report, memorial, descendant scholarshipDegree programme, course, faculty line
Evidence of seriousnessNamed people, published research, money movedDegrees conferred, students enrolled, post-release outcomes
Characteristic failureA document with no budget lineA programme that survives on one grant
Who audits itDescendants, faculty, occasionally state legislaturesCorrections departments, funders, rarely anyone else

Most institutions appear on one side of that table. A handful appear on both, and those are the ones worth arguing about.

A Virginia working group became the field's infrastructure

In 2015 the University of Virginia's President's Commission on Slavery and the University convened an informal group with four other Virginia institutions. Within months six more joined. After a teach-in at Georgetown that December, the consortium renamed itself Universities Studying Slavery and opened membership to any institution that wanted it, which is where the story stops being local.

It now lists more than a hundred members across the United States, Canada, Colombia, Scotland, Ireland and England, meeting twice a year to swap methods. The December 2025 roster reads like a cross-section of American higher education rather than a list of usual suspects: Harvard and Yale sit beside Morgan State, Hampton, Norfolk State, Emory, Tulane, Virginia Tech, Bard and John Jay College of Criminal Justice. A community college appears alongside research universities with nine-figure endowments.

UVA inherited the template from Brown, where president Ruth Simmons appointed a steering committee in 2003 and published a 106-page report in 2006 — the first serious institutional examination of its kind. Brown's own account credits that report with prompting similar reckonings at more than a hundred colleges and universities, a claim that is hard to verify and easy to believe.

The ten, sorted by what can be verified rather than by reputation

Ordering is arguable; the entries are not. Each row states the work and the caveat that belongs beside it.

InstitutionThe workThe caveat
Brown University2006 Slavery and Justice Report; Ruth J. Simmons Center for the Study of Slavery and Justice, opened 2012 and endowed and renamed in 2023The centre grew from a recommendation, not from a settlement of any claim
University of VirginiaPresident's Commission on Slavery and the University, 2013; Memorial to Enslaved Laborers, 2020; founded and hosts the consortiumRoughly 1,000 names inscribed, most only first names, against an estimated 4,000 people enslaved
Georgetown University2016 working-group report and apology; legacy admissions treatment for GU272 descendants; fundraising for descendant communitiesThe board declined to impose the student fee; the fund became a campaign instead
Harvard University2022 report of a 14-member committee; $100 million commitment accepted in fullDocumented more than 70 people enslaved; a 2024 Crimson investigation reported the initiative had since identified 300 and was slowed by turnover
William & MaryLemon Project, established 2009; Hearth: Memorial to the Enslaved, dedicated May 2022; descendant scholarship under state law199 blocks for 199 documented people; names are added as research finds them
Bard CollegeBard Prison Initiative, founded 1999; associate and bachelor's degrees in seven New York facilities; Consortium for the Liberal Arts in Prison, 2009More than 900 degrees conferred; recidivism below 4 percent, by its own accounting
Yale UniversityYale Prison Education Initiative at Dwight Hall, joined the consortium in 2017Launched on a three-year seed grant from Bard's programme, which is worth remembering when reading about Yale's initiative
Washington University in St. LouisPrison Education Project, 2014; associate and bachelor's degree study at two Missouri facilities78 degree-seeking students; all 41 alumni employed or in further study, by the programme's count
University of Puget SoundPartner in the first bachelor's degree in liberal arts offered inside Washington prisons, with the Freedom Education Project of Puget SoundThe nonprofit runs the programme and raises the money; the degree carries the university's name
Bennington CollegePrison Education Initiative at Great Meadow Correctional Facility, in the consortium since 2016New York announced Great Meadow's closure in July 2024; the programme had to move

Two entries deserve more than a table cell. UVA's memorial is the most carefully evidenced object on this list: an 80-foot granite circle the same diameter as the Rotunda it stands near, built with $3.5 million raised from more than 1,000 donors, designed by Höweler+Yoon with the historian Mabel O. Wilson after five months of meetings with descendants and Charlottesville residents. The design team found full names for 578 people and kinship links for another 311. The remaining space on the wall is deliberately blank, waiting.

William & Mary's Hearth does something UVA's circle cannot: it sits where the labour happened, beside the Wren Building, whose bricks were made by enslaved people. The Lemon Project began in 2009 after students passed a resolution demanding the college research and publish its record. It is named for a man the college enslaved, which is one way of keeping the ledger open.

a statue in front of a building

Photo by Hanyang Zhang on Unsplash

Harvard's hundred million and the problem of counting

The largest cheque on this list came with the largest counting problem. Harvard's committee, chaired by Radcliffe dean Tomiko Brown-Nagin, documented that presidents, faculty and staff had enslaved more than 70 people in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, and that five men who made their fortunes from slavery and slave-produced goods accounted for more than a third of all private donations to the college in the first half of the nineteenth century. The Harvard & the Legacy of Slavery initiative received $100 million, some of it endowed.

Two years later, a Crimson investigation reported that the initiative had identified 300 people enslaved at Harvard — more than four times the published figure — and that the work had been hindered by staff turnover and internal disagreement about scope. Both facts can be true. A first report counts what a committee could document in eighteen months; sustained research counts what exists. The 70 was never a total, though it was widely reported as one.

This is the ordinary arithmetic of institutional history: the number goes up when someone keeps looking. The question worth asking of any such report is not whether its figure is too low, but whether the fund it created keeps paying after the announcement cycle ends.

Georgetown: what a student vote can and cannot bind

In April 2019, Georgetown undergraduates voted 2,541 to 1,304 to add $27.20 per semester to their own bills, the amount chosen to echo the 272 people the Maryland Jesuits sold in 1838 to clear the college's debts — a sale that raised about $115,000, or roughly $3 million in today's money. The fee would have generated something over $400,000 a year for descendant communities in Louisiana and Maryland.

The board did not impose it. President John DeGioia wrote that the university embraced the spirit of the proposal and would instead run a fundraising campaign targeting at least the same annual sum, directed at community projects. Students for GU272 responded that a debt had been converted into a philanthropy. That criticism has not aged badly.

The rest of Georgetown's record is more substantial than the referendum episode suggests. A 2016 working group produced a report and a formal apology; two buildings were renamed, one for Isaac Hawkins, the first person listed on the 1838 bill of sale; descendants were given legacy consideration in admissions. More than 8,000 descendants have since been identified, which turns an abstract obligation into a mailing list.

The prison side does the harder arithmetic

Bard College is the only institution on this list whose abolitionist work is measured in transcripts. The Bard Prison Initiative started in 1999 as a student volunteer project by Max Kenner, began awarding credit in 2001, and now enrols more than 400 incarcerated students across seven New York facilities, conferring more than 900 Bard degrees to date. Students write senior projects and take calculus. There are no remedial courses. In 2015 the programme's debate team beat Harvard's.

Its stated recidivism figure, below 4 percent, is the number that gets quoted, and BPI's own alumni have argued in print that recidivism is a poor measure of what a liberal arts education does — a blunt failure metric that cannot capture whether a person can parent, work or think. They're right, and the honesty is unusual. Most programmes would rather you didn't ask what their headline number leaves out.

The replication model is more consequential than the flagship. In 2009 Bard set up the Consortium for the Liberal Arts in Prison and began helping other institutions build their own programmes, among them Wesleyan, Grinnell, Notre Dame, Goucher, the University of Vermont, Washington University in St. Louis, Bennington and, notably, Yale, which launched its initiative on a three-year seed grant from Bard. Washington University's project now runs across two Missouri facilities and reports that all 41 of its returning alumni are employed or in further study.

Bennington's experience is the cautionary one. After nine years teaching at Great Meadow, the college learned the facility would close; the programme moved to another site. An abolitionist curriculum housed inside a prison is a tenant, not an owner. Nobody in this field controls the building.

Courses are cheaper than programmes, and they show

The curricular wing of this work is thinner and more fragile than the memorial wing. Berkeley's Ethnic Studies department lists a four-unit course, Prison Abolition, that takes Ruth Wilson Gilmore's "abolition geographies" as its organising idea. Vassar offers Prison Abolition and Black Liberation, taught by Jasmine Syedullah, which reads Davis, James, Jackson, Kaba and Gilmore. Stanford's CSRE 123, Beyond Incarceration: Imagining a World Without Prisons, was last offered in summer 2023.

A course is a real thing. It is also the cheapest possible unit of institutional commitment: one instructor, one room, no capital campaign. The presence of these courses is evidence that the ideas have reached the curriculum. Their scheduling pattern is evidence that nobody has promised they'll stay.

grayscale photo of 2 women standing on the street

Photo by mana5280 on Unsplash

What the announcements leave out

Legislatures occasionally supply the accountability that institutions decline to impose on themselves. Since 2021, Virginia law has required five public institutions — William & Mary, Longwood, Virginia Commonwealth, the Virginia Military Institute and UVA — to identify and memorialise people enslaved on their grounds and to fund scholarships or community development for descendants, without state money. Their November 2025 report describes five genuinely different approaches, which is what happens when a mandate sets an obligation and not a method.

That's the useful lesson from the whole set. The design of these programmes determines what they can show. A commission that reports to a president can be closed by the next president. A fund with an endowment and a named beneficiary population is harder to discontinue. A prison programme with no capital and no tenure line is one warden's reassignment away from ending.

Which leaves the question the announcements tend to avoid. When the memorial is dedicated, the report is filed and the coverage moves to the next campus, which line in the operating budget pays for year eleven — and who at the institution has the standing to insist that it does?

  • higher-education-news
  • higher-education-news
  • prison-abolition
  • prison-abolition
  • abolitionist-movement
Portrait of Prof. Marcus Blackwell
About the author

Prof. Marcus BlackwellView author

Academic Jobs In House Author

Marcus Blackwell is a Contributing Writer at AcademicJobs and one of our main news creators, shaping the future of academia through his specialist knowledge in research methodologies and innovation. Holding a doctorate…

Discussion

Sort by:

Be the first to comment on this article!

You

You’ll be asked to sign in before your comment is posted.

Browse by Faculty

Browse by Subject

Frequently Asked Questions

📜What counts as an abolitionist university?

Two different kinds of work get that label. One is legacy of slavery reckoning, where an institution researches how it was built on enslaved labour and commits money, admissions policy or memorials to the descendants. The other is prison abolition, where colleges run degree programmes inside prisons or teach the intellectual case against carceral punishment. A few institutions do both. Most do one and describe it as the other.

📊Is there a formal ranking of universities on slavery reparations?

No. There is no accrediting body, common metric or published league table. Universities Studying Slavery maintains a membership list of more than a hundred institutions, which is not a ranking. Any top ten you read, including this one, is a judgment call with visible criteria.

🤝What is the Universities Studying Slavery consortium?

It began in 2015 as an informal working group of Virginia institutions convened by the University of Virginia's President's Commission on Slavery and the University. After a teach-in at Georgetown that December it renamed itself and opened to any institution. Members meet twice a year to share research methods, descendant engagement practice and findings. It now spans the United States, Canada, Colombia, Scotland, Ireland and England.

🏛️Which university produced the first major slavery examination?

Brown University, where president Ruth Simmons appointed a steering committee in 2003. Its 106-page report appeared in 2006 and recommended a research centre, a memorial and a public accounting of the university's ties to the transatlantic slave trade. The centre opened in 2012 and was renamed and endowed in honour of Simmons in 2023.

💰How much did Harvard commit to its legacy of slavery initiative?

Harvard pledged $100 million in April 2022 when it accepted in full the recommendations of a 14-member committee chaired by Tomiko Brown-Nagin. Some of the money is held in an endowment. The committee documented more than 70 people enslaved by Harvard affiliates; a 2024 Crimson investigation reported that later research had identified 300 and that the initiative had been slowed by staff turnover.

🗳️Did Georgetown ever charge students the reparations fee they voted for?

No. Undergraduates voted 2,541 to 1,304 in April 2019 for a $27.20 per semester fee benefiting descendants of the 272 people sold in 1838. The vote was non-binding and the board did not impose it. Georgetown instead committed to a fundraising campaign targeting at least the same annual amount, about $400,000, for community projects in descendant areas. Students for GU272 criticised the shift from debt repayment to philanthropy.

🎓What does the Bard Prison Initiative actually award?

Associate in arts and bachelor of arts degrees from Bard College, taught inside seven New York State correctional facilities. It has conferred more than 900 degrees and enrols over 400 incarcerated students. Admission is competitive and there are no remedial courses. Its own published record reports recidivism below 4 percent, a figure its alumni have argued is a crude measure of educational value.

📚Which universities offer prison abolition courses?

UC Berkeley's Ethnic Studies department lists a four-unit Prison Abolition course built around Ruth Wilson Gilmore's concept of abolition geographies. Vassar teaches Prison Abolition and Black Liberation, reading Davis, Kaba, Gilmore, Jackson and Syedullah. Stanford's CSRE 123, Beyond Incarceration, was last offered in summer 2023. Courses are the cheapest form of institutional commitment and the easiest to stop scheduling.

⚖️What does Virginia law require of its public universities?

Since 2021 the Enslaved Ancestors College Access Scholarship and Memorial Program has required five institutions — the University of Virginia, William & Mary, Longwood, Virginia Commonwealth and the Virginia Military Institute — to identify and memorialise people enslaved on their grounds and to fund scholarships or community development for descendants, without using state money. A November 2025 report describes five distinct approaches to the same obligation.

🔍Why do universities' estimates of enslaved people keep rising?

Because first reports count what a committee can document within a fixed period, not what existed. Harvard published a figure above 70 and later research identified 300. UVA inscribed roughly 1,000 names, most of them first names, against an estimated 4,000 people enslaved between 1817 and 1865. Rising numbers are usually a sign of continuing research rather than earlier error.

🧭What is the most common failure mode of these programmes?

Legacy work often ends as a document with no recurring budget line, vulnerable to a change of president. Prison programmes often depend on a single grant or on one facility staying open — Bennington College had to relocate its programme after New York announced Great Meadow's closure in 2024. Endowed funds and statute-backed obligations survive leadership changes better than commissions do.