At a glance
A qualitative study of eleven Javanese women over 60 living alone in Surabaya finds that most did not feel lonely, crediting Guyub culture and material, emotional and companionship support. Instrumental and informational help were thin, and the authors call for stronger family and community networks.
Eleven women live alone in Simomulyo Baru, a crowded neighbourhood wedged among commercial and office districts in the centre of Surabaya, Indonesia's second-largest city. The youngest is 60. The oldest is 81. By the usual arithmetic of ageing and isolation, they should be among the loneliest people in the city.
Most of them say they are not lonely at all.
That gap between expectation and account is the subject of a study published on 1 September 2025 in Frontiers in Sociology by Ayu Diah Amalia, Achmadi Jayaputra and Nurasih Shamadiyah. Their case is not that loneliness among older people is imaginary. It is that loneliness is a subjective experience, filtered through culture and through who actually turns up, and that a neighbourhood can quietly perform work that no welfare programme was designed to do.
The timing matters. Across Asia, governments are writing elder-care policy for populations that live longer and, increasingly, live alone. Most of those policies are built from household registers: who shares an address with whom, who is listed as a carer, who qualifies for an allowance. Amalia's team points at a line missing from that ledger. In Simomulyo Baru, informal obligations between neighbours appear to carry more weight than any formal provision.
Guyub: the expectation that neighbours behave like family
The authors attribute much of what they found to Guyub, the Javanese ethic of close-knit communal life in which residents are expected to treat one another's troubles as shared business. It shows up in small, unglamorous routines. Prayers at the mosque. A monthly savings club. Group exercise once a week. Assistance with a funeral, a hospital visit, a bag of groceries.
What makes the finding harder to dismiss is where it was recorded. Simomulyo Baru is not an insulated rural hamlet. The authors describe a densely populated inner-city area with high mobility and what they call individualistic tendencies, home to a mix of lower-middle and upper-middle class residents in small, medium and large houses. Nine of the eleven women had moved to Surabaya from elsewhere, though all had lived at the address for years, often decades. If Guyub can operate here, the argument goes, the variable worth studying is not urbanisation but the strength of local networks.
Five kinds of support, and two that run thin
The research leans on a standard taxonomy of social support, and the split in what was available is one of the more useful things in the paper.
- Material support — money and goods, mostly from adult children working away from home. One 66-year-old participant, identified in the paper as ASI, put it plainly: her children send money because she no longer works.
- Emotional support — affection, reassurance, someone to confide in. Faith carried some of this load. A 76-year-old participant, YAT, described feeling that God was with her and sensing her late husband's presence in the house.
- Companionship support — shared time and activity. This was the most visible form in the neighbourhood, and it came bundled with prayer groups, exercise sessions and savings clubs.
- Instrumental support — practical help with tasks, transport, repairs, the physical labour of daily life. The authors report this was largely absent outside the family.
- Informational support — advice and guidance. What existed was often self-served through phones and the internet rather than given by others. One 76-year-old, identified as Ss, still talks to former colleagues online.
That last pair matters for anyone thinking about policy. Material, emotional and companionship support are the kinds that make solitude bearable. Instrumental support is the kind that determines whether an 81-year-old can stay in her own home after her knees give out. The paper documents a community that is warm but not equipped.
A club called Paguyuban Werdho Tomo
At the centre of the neighbourhood's social machinery sits an elderly association, Paguyuban Werdho Tomo, run by local residents and sited close enough for members to walk to. It hosts exercise, health checks, charity work and occasional outings, and functions as a communication hub for people whose children live in other cities.
"I want activities so I don't become senile. The elderly's dependence needs to be helped, and more attention should be given to the elderly. Here, there's an elderly group, called Paguyuban Werdho Tomo. The location is easily accessible for the elderly, with activities like exercise and sometimes recreation." — SUS, 77
Another participant, NAR, 81, laid out a week that would exhaust many people half her age: prayer group, savings club, the neighbourhood women's welfare group known as PKK, exercise once a week, savings meetings once a month, and mosque prayers at dawn, dusk and night. A 76-year-old, MUR, described neighbours who check on her and gather with her for prayers and exercise.
The authors read these routines through activity theory, the long-standing idea that healthy ageing depends on replacing roles lost to retirement and bereavement with new ones. They also reach for gerotranscendence, a theory holding that older people often become more selective about social contact and can find genuine value in solitude. Not every participant was a joiner. One introvert, RUS, managed largely through television and YouTube at home. The paper resists treating her as a failure case.
Where the model cracks
Not everyone in the study escaped loneliness, and the exceptions are revealing. The women who did feel lonely tended to trace it to family rupture rather than to an empty house. One participant, EMI, was isolated after an inheritance dispute. Another, MUR, described generational conflict and incompatibility with a child. In both cases the community absorbed some of the shock, but the wound was relational, not logistical.
The authors make a broader point from this. Loneliness in later life, they write, is more often produced by generational conflict and difference than by solitary living as such. That reframing has consequences. A programme that measures success by how many older people are enrolled in activities will miss the woman whose daughter has stopped calling.
Eleven women, one neighbourhood, and the limits of a story
The design is deliberately small. The team used narrative analysis, a qualitative method that treats the stories people tell as data in their own right, examining not just what was said but how it was framed, which events were sequenced where, and what cultural assumptions sat underneath. Interviews ran one to two hours and took place in participants' homes. Researchers also observed the surrounding streets, watched daily routines, looked at participants' social media activity, and interviewed neighbours, community figures and elderly leaders to cross-check accounts. Transcripts were coded in NVivo, the standard qualitative analysis software.
The paper is open access, and the full text repays reading for the interview excerpts alone. A PubMed record lists the abstract and citation details.
What the study cannot do is tell you how common this is. Eleven women in one Surabaya neighbourhood, recruited through community leaders, are not a sample of Indonesia's older population, and the authors are explicit that further work is needed on how cultural and social context shapes loneliness. The participants are all women — chosen because older women in the area more often live alone after widowhood and outlive men — so the paper says nothing about older men living by themselves. Loneliness here was explored through interviews rather than measured with a standardised scale, which buys depth and forfeits comparability. And the women who agreed to sit down for two hours with a researcher are, almost by definition, the ones still plugged into neighbourhood life. The most isolated resident on the street is unlikely to have opened the door.
The uncomfortable question for policy
There is a version of this finding that gets quoted too easily, in which Asian collectivism is held up as a natural antidote to a Western loneliness epidemic. The paper's own details resist that. Most participants received no social assistance; three had economic limitations and only one was receiving any government support. Taking part in neighbourhood activities cost money, even if the dues were low, and the local government chipped in food for group gatherings. The safety net described here is cheap, but it is not free, and it rests on the unpaid labour of residents who are themselves ageing.
That is the practical question the research leaves open. Paguyuban Werdho Tomo works because somebody organises the exercise sessions and knocks on doors. In ten years, that somebody will be eighty. Whether the model survives its own founders is a question for city governments, not for the sociologists who documented it.
Still, the study lands a clean blow against a lazy assumption. Living alone and being lonely are different measurements, and a household register can only see one of them. Amalia and her colleagues argue that the sensible response is to strengthen family and community networks so that neighbourhoods become genuinely friendly to older residents — not to assume that a woman on her own is a problem waiting to be solved.
Photo by Eugene Chystiakov on Unsplash
- gerontology
- ageing-population
- social-support
- qualitative-research
- elderly-loneliness

